On 11 November 2026 the Advertising Standards Authority published four rulings on the same three-word idea: carbon neutral (or carbon positive) delivery. The ads came from ProCook, Grind, Who Gives A Crap and SportsShoes.com. All four were upheld.
None of these brands was accused of inventing its green credentials. Each could explain how its delivery emissions were handled. The problem was simpler and far more common: the ads didn't say.
The rule: the basis of the claim belongs in the ad
CAP rule 11.1 says the basis of an environmental claim must be clear. Rule 3.3 adds that an ad can mislead by leaving out material information. CAP's guidance adds that ads should say whether, and to what degree, carbon neutrality comes from cutting emissions or from offsetting.
In all three rulings we read, the claim depended on offsetting credits. ProCook's delivery partner had cut some emissions and offset the rest. Grind funded a carbon removal scheme for each delivery. Who Gives A Crap bought verified credits with a 10% buffer. None of that reached the ad.
Lesson: "carbon neutral" is a conclusion. The ad has to show the working, or at least say where the number comes from.
Scope was fine. Method was missing.
The brands argued their claims covered delivery or shipping only, not the whole product life cycle. The ASA agreed with them on that.
But getting the scope right didn't save the ads. Consumers couldn't tell whether neutrality came from offsets or from removing the source of the emissions. Scope says what a claim covers; method says how it was achieved. The rule needs both.
Lesson: a precisely scoped claim can still mislead if it hides how the result was reached.
"There wasn't room" is not a defence
ProCook's and Grind's ads were Google search ads, the tightest format most brands use. The ASA still found room: each ad allowed 270 characters, which it said was not so limited that the basis of the claim couldn't be made clear.
It also checked where the ads led. In all three rulings, the landing page didn't explain the basis of the claim either.
Lesson: if a claim can't be qualified in the space available, it probably shouldn't run in that space.
The legacy-ad trap
The most useful detail in these rulings is how the ads survived. Grind had decided over a year earlier to replace "Carbon Positive" wording, but this search ad was missed in that review. ProCook said its ad was part of a legacy campaign. To its credit, it removed the ad and began an internal audit of all historical ads. Who Gives A Crap began reviewing its environmental claims in May 2026, and has since added a link on its website explaining the basis of its shipping claim.
Old copy rarely gets a second look in always-on search campaigns. Yet the rulings say these ads were identified through ASA intelligence and its Active Ad Monitoring system, which uses AI to search for online ads that might break the rules. That system scanned 40 million ads and potential ads in the first half of 2026 alone (ASA). In advertising compliance, a forgotten ad is not an invisible one.
Lesson: a claims clean-up is only finished when every live ad, in every channel, has been checked.
One cross-border note: since 27 September 2026, EU rules ban claims that a product has a neutral or positive climate impact based on offsetting (Lewis Silkin). In the UK you must explain such a claim; in the EU you may not be able to make it at all.
What to check before your next campaign
- Does every environmental claim ("carbon neutral", "carbon positive", "net zero") say what it covers and how it is achieved?
- If the claim relies on offsetting, does the ad say so, not just a page elsewhere?
- Does the landing page explain the basis of the claim in plain words?
- Have legacy and always-on ads, especially search ads, been checked against current wording?
- Will the same creative run in the EU, where offset-based neutrality claims are now banned?
- Is there a named person who signs off green claims before launch?
Getting sign-off right at speed
Environmental claims hide in small places: a search headline, a caption, a homepage banner. Each of the 11 November rulings turned on a few words a careful review could have flagged. The catch is volume, which is how legacy ads slip through.
That is the job Voxly Vision was built for. It checks images, video and copy against regulations and brand guidelines before launch and flags issues for a person to review. Diageo uses it to cut ad sign-off from more than three days to about an hour, with review time per asset down from 5-10 minutes to about 60 seconds. A person still makes the final call.
Voxly Vision





























